The catholic debate against stem cell research and embryonic cloning essay

The practice of science, as such, is non-ideological; and the acquisition of knowledge has been a basic objective of all modern societies. Somatic cell nuclear transfer is the laboratory creation of a viable embryo by implanting a donor nucleus from a body cell into an egg cell.

Since In-vitro fertilisation IVF is a root cell therapy and s of embryologic root cells used in the procedure are discarded. Spare frozen embryos at reproductive clinics, embryos that have been deliberately created for research purposes using sperm and ova and cloned embryos.

Indeed, it is her conviction that everything human, including scientific research, "is not only received and respected by faith, but is also purified, elevated and perfected" ibid. Surely these embryos, already destined for destruction, could be utilized in research?

Parel has explained the suspicion in the following way: This is clearly stated in the ethical and religious directives for catholic health care services, a document from the United States conference of catholic bishops.

In particular, three elements of the argument will be considered. Embryonic stem cells are easier to obtain; they have a greater cell growth, otherwise known as proliferation, capacity; and they are more versatile.

For embryos created via in vitro fertilization, the researchers using the embryos are not making a decision that results in the loss of a future life. Up to this point, therefore, stem cell research may be permissible.

They further belief that a human being is a complex of a organic structure and psyche which is a direct creative activity of God.

The topic is stem cell research and regenerative medicine.

Fresh Writing

For these reasons, in combination with the possibility of reducing suffering for future beings, embryonic stem cell research is ethical under certain circumstances.

Therefore a cell can non be called a human being but can be seen as merely a portion of the procedure that may take to formation of a human being. Of course, the fact that stem cell research is closely associated with cloning is in and of itself enough to make the entire agenda highly controversial for many Americans.

Stem Cell Research

Moral implications of stem cell experimentation on an embryo Pro-life supporters argue the destruction of the embryo would be morally unacceptable, and it would thus not be acceptable to use it as a means toward the alleviation of suffering.

Similarly, what of embryos destroyed or deemed defective by other technologies such as pre-implantation genetic diagnosis PGD? The response to this problem is that the particular blastocysts that are harvested for embryonic stem cell research are taken from 1 embryos that are frozen during in vitro fertilization procedures and never implanted, 2 donated egg cells, and 3 embryos created specifically for the purpose of generating new stem cell lines.

The controversial use of embryonic stem cells is supported on the basis of the many advantages that they have over adult stem cells. Donated egg cells can be fertilized in a lab or through somatic cell nuclear transfer, a process described earlier in this paper. The first pertains to what has been called the moral doctrine of double effect, which stipulates that it is never acceptable to utilize a morally unacceptable action as a means toward achieving a moral end, no matter how good that end may be.

In any event, such emerging technologies help address competing for moral concerns and thus relatively bolster the moral imperative to alleviate suffering.

From this it is very clear that using the blastocyst in pursuit of a cure to a disease is more beneficial than just throwing them away. In each of these cases, the embryo at hand does not have a future life in plan and therefore, nothing is lost by using such embryonic stem cells for research.

The book presents the reader with an engaging, comprehensive overview of adult stem cells and their vital role in the future of regenerative medicine. How many news reports have you read over the years insinuating that the Catholic Church is against "stem cell research"?

Catholic Support for Ethically Acceptable Stem Cell Research

For the cells to develop into a human being requires an interactive process in the uterus between the embryo and the mother" Clemmitt From the document the Catholic Church asks its health care institutions not to make use of human tissue that are obtained from direct abortions even for research and therapeutic purposes Shannon, Thomas A."Research or experimentation on the human being cannot legitimate acts that are in themselves contrary to the dignity of persons and to the moral law.

The subjects' potential consent does not justify such acts. The controversy surrounding stem cell research led to an intense debate about ethics. Up until the recent years, the research method mainly focused on Embryonic Stem Cells, which involves taking tissue from an aborted embryo to get proper material to study.

Sample Essay on the Argument in Favor of Stem Cell Research and Cloning

Debates over the ethics of embryonic stem cell research continue to divide scientists, politicians, and religious groups. However, promising developments in other areas of stem cell research might lead to solutions that bypass these ethical issues.

According to the argument against stem cell research, the embryo is a fully living human being; therefore, the destruction of embryos for the purposes of scientific research would be completely unacceptable/5(5).

This is a problem that will require a solution if embryonic stem cell research is to be the basis for future therapeutic medicine.

Arguments against Embryonic Stem Cell Research. Currently, the isolation of embryonic stem cells requires the destruction of an early embryo. The Catholic Debate against Stem Cell Research and Embryonic Cloning Essay Sample Stem cells have an ability of developing into different cell types.

Scientists’ beliefs that stem cell research may offer a renewable supply of replacement cells to be used in cell-based therapies to treat diseases, which are often referred to are generative or.

The Catholic Debate against Stem Cell Research and Embryonic Cloning Essay Sample Download
The catholic debate against stem cell research and embryonic cloning essay
Rated 0/5 based on 94 review